![]() If the new brain were put into the old body, would the same human being exist or a new human being who made use of the body of the old one? I am inclined to suppose the latter.īut consider the entity whose brain has died. The new brain bears no relation to the old one (it has none of its memory traces, and so on). Imagine that medical technology has reached the stage at which, when brain death occurs, the brain is removed, “liquified,” and “recast” into a new functioning brain. īrody responds to this criticism by presenting the following science-fiction case: Death means the end of natural growth, the cessation of these abilities. The embryo contains the natural capacity to develop all the human activities: perceiving, reasoning, willing and relating to others. The two stages of human life are, then, entirely different from the point of view of brain functioning. She is like a patient with a temporarily flat EEG. However, the unborn entity who has yet to reach the stage in (his or) her development at which brain waves can be detected, unlike the brain dead individual, possesses the inherent capacity to have brain waves. That is to say, an entity's irreversible absence of brain waves after the brain waves have come into existence indicates that the entity no longer has the natural, inherent capacity to function as a human being, since our current technology is incapable of “reactivating” the brain. ![]() But the developing embryo has the natural capacity to bring on the functioning of the brain. The fundamental difficulty with this argument is that…īrain death indicates the end of human life as we know it, the dead brain having no capacity to revive itself. Hence, it would only follow that the start of brain functioning is the beginning of full humanness. He concludes that since at brain death a human being goes out of existence (at least in this mortal realm), the presence of a functioning human brain is the property which makes one fully human. Brody maintains that in order to decide when something is fully human, “we must first see… what properties are such that their loss would mean the going out of existence (the death) of a human being.” Īlthough Brody has moral problems with abortion on demand prior to brain functioning, this is not because he believes the unborn is fully human. S ome bioethicists, such as Baruch Brody, believe that full humanness begins when the brain starts functioning, which can first be detected by the electroencephalogram (EEG) at about 40 to 43 days after conception. Does life begin only when the brain starts functioning?
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |